Following the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in
WWII, the globe was effectively destabilized and a strong nuclear threat
remained even into the 21st century.
Recognizing the immense danger posed by atomic weaponry, Porter’s 1950
essay “The Future Is Now” took an unclear stance that while atomic warfare is
dangerous, it should not be a cause of major concern. Porter, recognizing that
she was speaking to Americans following WWII, commanded that “[i]n his pride to
explore his universe to its unimaginable limits and to exceed his possible
powers, [humans have] at last produced an embarrassing series of engines too
powerful for their containers,” (Porter 196) which suggests Porter’s disapproval
of atomic warfare. Later, she maintains, “I fail entirely to see why it is more
criminal to kill a few thousand persons in one instant than it is to kill the
same number slowly over a period of time,” (Porter 198) effectively delivering
a counterargument to the destructiveness and damage caused by atomic bombs.
Likewise, Porter upholds that “the invention of every new weapon of war has
always been greeted with horror and righteous indignation,” (Porter 197)
essentially stating that while there is fear surrounding the atomic bomb, we
must move forward as a society. Evidently, the threat of nuclear arms is a
constant topic of discussion even today in 2017, a clear disruption of global
communication and cooperation. Thus, Porter underestimated the impact of this
new warfare entirely, as it redefined military balance of power to require
these incalculably destructive bombs. She optimistically exclaims, “it may be
that what we have is a world not on the verge of flying apart, but an uncreated
one … still in shapeless fragments,” (Porter 198) suggesting that atomic bombs
will likely not cause global tensions. Still in the early stages of this new
type of warfare, Porter did not effectively recognize the long-term impacts
that these immediate threats may pose on a global level, invalidating a central
position of her argument.
Works Cited
Porter,
Katherine Anne. “The Future Is Now.” The Best American Essays of the
Century, Edited by Joyce Carol Oates and Robert Atwan, Houghton Mifflin,
Boston, MA, 2000, pp. 193–198.
No comments:
Post a Comment